Dynamical algebraic combinatorics
March 23 to March 27, 2015
American Institute of Mathematics,
San Jose, California
and Nathan Williams
This workshop will focus on dynamical systems arising from algebraic
combinatorics. Some well-known examples of actions on combinatorial objects
are the following:
Of particular relevance to this workshop are the actions and dynamical systems
- promotion and evacuation for Young tableaux;
- the action of a Coxeter element on a parabolic quotient of a Coxeter
- crystal operators on highest-weight representations.
A unifying theme is the central role played by involutions, such as the
Bender-Knuth involutions whose composition gives promotion of Young tableaux and
the toggle operations whose composition gives rowmotion of order ideals.
Typical questions we ask in various contexts are: Why does this product of
involutions --- a permutation on a large set --- have such small order? (Or, if
it has large order, why does the action nevertheless resonate with a small
integer $p$ as a pseudo-period, in the sense that most orbit-sizes are multiples
of $p$?) Why do certain combinatorially significant numerical functions
(statistics) on the set have the property that the average value of the function
on each orbit is the same for all orbits (the homomesy phenomenon)?
- promotion and rowmotion for order ideals and antichains in posets; and
- their piecewise-linear and birational liftings.
Some of the properties of these cyclic actions can be explained by the
importation of combinatorial or algebraic models that explain why the action
exists. When the cyclic action has predictable orbit structure, this program
has been very successful (as seen in the recent flurry of work on the cyclic
sieving phenomenon). The encoding of alternating sign matrices under gyration
by fully packed loops and their associated link-patterns shows that such models
can exist even when the orbits of the cyclic action display resonance and some
are quite large. We hope to study further actions of this last sort, such as
rowmotion on plane partitions of height greater than two.
Some examples of problems we are interested in are:
The main goals of the workshop are:
- Develop a combinatorial model of alternating sign matrices of size n that
explains the existence of the cyclic action, superpromotion, of pseudo-period
$3n-2$ with properties similar to gyration.
- Uniformly prove that birational promotion and rowmotion have finite order on
all minuscule posets.
- Express known combinatorial actions as compositions of piecewise-linear
involutions and investigate their birational analogues.
- Uniformly prove a bijection between nonnesting partitions and clusters
related to Panyushev's homomesy conjectures.
- To produce new combinatorial models that explain the existence of known cyclic
actions and homomesies.
- To use data provided by cyclic actions, invariants, and homomesies to produce
new bijections between combinatorial objects.
- To coordinate work on homomesy and generalized toggle group actions.
- To suggest directions for future research.
Material from the workshop
A list of participants.
The workshop schedule.
A report on the workshop activities.
A list of workshop notes and open problems, by Sam Hopkins.
A pre-workshop problem list prepared by the organizers.
One of the outcomes of the workshop was the creation of
a Dynamical Algebraic Combinatorics ("DAC") listserv.
To join, send email to James Propp.
Papers arising from the workshop:
Resonance in orbits of plane partitions and increasing tableaux
by Kevin Dilks, Oliver Pechenik and Jessica Striker, J. Combin. Theory Ser. A 148 (2017), 244–274 MR3603321
Noncrossing partitions, toggles, and homomesies
by David Einstein, Miriam Farber, Emily Gunawan, Michael Joseph, Matthew Macauley, James Propp and Simon Rubinstein-Salzedo, Electron. J. Combin. 23 (2016), no. 3, Paper 3.52, 26 pp MR3576300
The CDE property for minuscule lattices
by Sam Hopkins, J. Combin. Theory Ser. A 152 (2017), 45–103 MR3682727
Braid moves in commutation classes of the symmetric group
by Anne Schilling, Nicolas M. Thiéry, Graham White and Nathan Williams, European J. Combin. 62 (2017), 15–34 MR3621720
Genera of Brill-Noether curves and staircase paths in Young tableaux
by Melody Chan, Alberto López Mart&\acute;in, Nathan Pflueger and Montserrat Teixidor i Bigas, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 370 (2018), no. 5, 3405–3439 MR3766853
The expected jaggedness of order ideals
by Melody Chan, Shahrzad Haddadan, Sam Hopkins and Luca Moci, Forum Math. Sigma 5 (2017), e9, 27 pp MR3623577
Poset edge densities, nearly reduced words, and barely set-valued tableaux
by Victor Reiner, Bridget Eileen Tenner and Alexander Yong, J. Combin. Theory Ser. A 158 (2018), 66–125 MR3800124
Noncrossing partitions, toggles, and homomesies
by David Einstein, Miriam Farber, Emily Gunawan, Michael Joseph, Matthew Macauley, James Propp, Simon Rubinstein-Salzedo